Analysis of 115 Metros Shows Growth and Opportunity Both Matter in Recovery, Links Job Growth Alone to Inequality, Poverty and Crime.
Economic research guides the work of the Fund and helps identify what matters in our work to advance a growing, opportunity-rich economy for the people of Northeast Ohio. What Matters to Metros™: Foundational Indicators for Economic Competitiveness helps community leaders identify factors associated with economic growth in a post-recession economy.
Download the report and appendices. A complete, sortable data set is available by filling out the form at the bottom of this page.
This work builds upon six previous iterations (called The Dashboard of Economic Indicators; see bottom of WHAT MATTERS page) and assesses the relationship of 55 variables to economic growth across four measures: per capita income, gross metropolitan product (GMP), productivity and employment, between 1990 and 2011. Key observations include:
THE CRITICALITY OF EDUCATION AND INNOVATION. Together, higher education and innovation are associated with per capita income, productivity and GMP growth. The factor is neither positively nor negatively associated with job growth.
THE RISK OF JOB CREATION WITHOUT INCOME GENERATION. Many metros that experienced high levels of employment growth did not see these jobs translate into higher per capita income; in fact, inequality, poverty and crime tended to be more prevalent in those metro areas that saw the most job gains.
THE BENEFITS OF DIVERSE ENTREPRENEURIAL ECOSYSTEMS. Business starts and/or self-employment are associated with every measure of growth: jobs, income, productivity and GMP, and are especially pronounced in metro areas with more diverse and integrated populations.
What Matters to Metros™ reinforced much of what we knew: specifically, that education and innovation are the bedrock of a healthy economy. But the research also presents surprising results that challenge many of our assumptions. Most noticeably, it suggests that metro areas with the most job growth tended to have the highest poverty, crime and income inequality, which will ultimately put that growth at risk. This disturbing trend makes it clear that a strong economy is defined not just by its growth, but also by how it grows. Economic growth must be accompanied by an increase in access to economic opportunity for historically isolated and disconnected populations, particularly those without the educational attainment or career readiness demanded by the marketplace and those cut off from job opportunities by unsustainable development patterns. Advocates for economic growth and advocates for increased opportunity need to join together and align their respective efforts to strengthen key industries, prepare talent for success, and connect and strengthen quality places.
WHAT MATTERS TO NORTHEAST OHIO
What Matters to Metros™ can serve civic leaders in metros throughout the United States, but the research bears specific implications for the four largest metropolitan areas in Northeast Ohio. In June 2013, four community forums were held in each of Northeast Ohio's four metros so community leaders could discuss local metro data, how "growth" can be pursued and their own distinct approaches to get there:
Video from each community forum is available. Join an online forum hosted by the The Civic Commons to engage with others interested in What Matters to Metros™.
For more information on What Matters™, please contact Emily Garr Pacetti (email@example.com).
To access the data, please fill out the form below.